Introduction
Detailed Explanation of Design Limitations of Each Method
Casting
Casting involves pouring liquid metal into a mold to form a part. Its accuracy and detail limitations are primarily influenced by the metal’s fluidity and cooling behavior.
- Sand Casting: This is the lowest-precision casting method (approximately ISO 8062 CT9-CT11 grades). Due to the lower strength of sand molds, its design limitations are the most stringent: wall thicknesses must be at least 5-10 mm, and internal corner radius must be ≥ 1.5-3 mm.
- Shell Mold Casting: Offers higher precision than sand molds (approximately CT8-CT10), allowing for slightly thinner wall thicknesses, down to 4-8 mm, but with similar R-angle limitations.
- Gravity/Low-Pressure Casting: Offers higher precision (approximately CT6-CT8) and enables the production of finer structures. Wall thicknesses can be reduced to 3-4 mm, while internal corner R-angles can reach 0.5-1.5 mm or greater.
- High-Pressure Die Casting: This is the most precise casting method (approximately CT5-CT6), capable of achieving local accuracies of ±0.05 mm. It can achieve very thin wall thicknesses (approximately 1.2-2.0 mm for aluminum parts) and very tight internal corner R-angles (0.25-0.5 mm or greater).
Forging
Forging deforms solid metal through pressure. Its precision is inferior to die casting (hot forging is approximately IT12-IT13). To ensure smooth material flow and easy demolding, large R-angles (R ≥ 2-3 mm) and draft angles are required.
Sheet/Tube Forming
This process typically achieves an accuracy of ±0.1–0.2 mm. Wall thickness is directly dependent on the thickness of the original sheet metal. Limitations on internal angles vary depending on the process. For example, the R-angle for stamping must be greater than the sheet thickness (R ≥ t), and the radius for pipe bends must be greater than 1–1.5 times the tube diameter (R ≥ 1–1.5D).
Metal Injection Molding (MIM)
MIM enables extremely fine designs, with wall thicknesses as thin as 0.5–1.5 mm and internal angles as small as R ≥ 0.2–0.5 mm. Dimensional tolerances are typically expressed as a percentage, approximately ±0.3–0.5%.
CNC Machining
CNC machining offers very high precision (reaching IT7–IT9). Theoretically, there are no absolute limits to wall thickness and R-angle, depending entirely on tool size and machine stability. Generally, to balance rigidity and cost, thin-wall thicknesses of 0.8–1.2 mm or greater are recommended.
Key Concepts
- Dimensional Accuracy: This refers to the degree to which the actual dimensions of the finished part conform to the design drawing. It is typically expressed in tolerance grades (such as ISO 8062 CT9) or tolerance ranges (such as ±0.1 mm). Smaller grades or narrower tolerance ranges indicate higher precision.
- Minimum Inside Corner Radius (R-angle): This refers to the minimum radius that can be machined on the inside corners of a part. Casting, forging, and other processes require an adequate R-angle to aid metal flow, reduce stress concentrations, and facilitate demolding.
- Minimum Wall Thickness (MWT) refers to the minimum thickness a part can achieve without causing defects (such as cold shuts and underfill). Designs that are too thin significantly increase production difficulty and reject rates.
Conclusion
As can be seen above, higher-precision methods (such as die casting and CNC) achieve smaller minimum wall thicknesses and radius radiuses, providing greater design freedom, but typically also at the expense of higher mold or unit costs. Conversely, lower-cost methods like sand casting require more flexibility in wall thickness and radius radius design. Taking these constraints into account at the initial design stage can effectively avoid subsequent design changes and ensure smooth mass production.

